Published: 2026-04-15

Why Do Management Scholars Avoid Experiments? A Necessary Provocation

João Fernandes Jorge de Siqueira, Rafael Barreiros Porto, Jonathan Simões Freitas
Abstract:

Despite the consolidation of experimental designs as a central standard for causal inference in adjacent fields, experiments remain peripheral in large segments of management research. This article argues that such marginalization is not primarily technical, but epistemic and institutional. It reconstructs six recurrent objections — complexity, external validity, feasibility, theory reduction, non-manipulability, and ethical scope — that structure skepticism toward experimentation and...

Read more →

Navigating the Academic Publication Landscape: Reflections on Peer Review, Editorial Practices, and Research Quality

Adamantios Diamantopoulos, Maria Gabriela Montanari, Jonny Mateus Rodrigues, Renata Andreoni Barboza
Abstract:

The academic publication landscape in marketing and management has changed greatly in the past decades. In this interview, Professor Adamantios Diamantopoulos reflects on increased competition in top journals, the rise of open-access outlets, higher methodological standards, and more complex editorial structures. Drawing on his experience as an author, reviewer, associate editor, and editor, he discusses changes in peer review, editorial roles, and the challenges of desk rejections and...

Read more →